Your Car Got Hit. Can You Choose Your Own Repair Shop and Get a Cash Payout?
Navigating the aftermath of a car accident is stressful enough without confusing insurance processes adding to the frustration. A common situation we encounter at Blue Rock Insurance involves clients who are not at fault in an accident. They often feel powerless during the repair process. Let’s walk through a recent, real-world situation to clarify your rights and the modern claims process.
The Scenario: A Clear-Cut Case with a Complicated Feel
Imagine a driver—let's call him Mark. Mark was driving through a local intersection when another motorist ran a stop sign and hit his car. The police report clearly stated the other driver was at fault.
Mark drives a 5-year-old SUV, and the damage was significant but repairable. He already has a trusted auto body shop in mind, one that his family has used for years.
He files a claim with the at-fault driver's insurance company (let's say they have Farmers). He expects the process to be simple. The insurance company will evaluate the damage. Then, they will issue a check. He plans to use that money to pay for the shop he has chosen.
Instead, the claims adjuster tells him they will run a preliminary estimate based on the photos Mark submits. Then, they will pay the repair shop directly for the initial estimate and any "supplemental" repairs found later.
Mark is confused. “Why can’t I just get the cash and handle it myself? Don’t I have the right to pick my own shop?”
The answer to his second question is a resounding yes. The process for the first question has simply evolved. Here’s a breakdown of what’s happening and the clear protocol to follow.
The Protocol: Your Step-by-Step Action Plan
When you're not at fault, you have the power to steer the process. Here are the two primary paths, with one being the most advantageous.
Path A: The Direct Approach (Handling the At-Fault Party's Insurance)
This is typically the most straightforward path. Your goal is to make the other driver's insurance company responsible for fixing your situation. You want to do this without relying on your own insurance policy.
File the Third-Party Claim: Contact the at-fault driver's insurance company directly to file the claim. Have their policy number and the details of the accident report ready.
Assert Your Right to Choose: Clearly inform the claims adjuster: “I have selected my repair facility. It is [Name of Your Chosen Shop]. I will be having the vehicle repaired there, and I need you to coordinate payment with them directly.”
Understand the Modern Workflow:
Photo-Based Estimate: The insurer will likely start with a digital estimate. This is now standard practice for efficiency.
Payment to the Shop: The insurer will send the initial payment for the estimate to your chosen shop.
Supplement Process: Once the shop begins work, they may find hidden damage. They will submit a "supplement" directly to the insurance adjuster, who will then approve and pay the additional cost. This protects you from being caught in the middle of payment disputes.
Why This Path Works: This approach maintains a clear insurance history. It also prevents you from having to pay your deductible. Additionally, it transfers the entire administrative responsibility to the insurance provider of the party at fault.
Path B: Using Your Own Collision Coverage (The Backup Plan)
If the other insurer is slow, uncooperative, or disputes liability, you can turn to your own policy.
File a Claim with Your Insurer: Use your own collision coverage to get the process moving quickly.
Pay Your Deductible: You must pay your deductible to the repair shop when you receive service.
Let Your Insurer Handle the Details: Your auto insurance company will pay for the repair costs. They will then request reimbursement from the insurance of the driver who is at fault. This process is known as subrogation and includes recovering your deductible as well.
When to Use This Path: This is an excellent option when you need a faster resolution or face resistance. The main downside is the upfront cost of your deductible, which you should get back once subrogation is complete.
Key Insights: Demystifying the "Why"
The old method often resulted in "supplemental" claims. This situation arose when the initial check was not enough. As a result, the car owner had to either pay the difference or seek additional funds.
“Can I ever get a cash payout?” A payout for the actual cash value of the damage is often available. This option is typically offered if you decide not to repair the car. It is also applicable if the car is declared a total loss. This can be a complex choice, as it may affect your car's title and value.
The Clear-Cut Solution: You Are in Control
The most important takeaway is that the car owner is never powerless. In Mark's case, the solution was simple:
He firmly but politely told the at-fault driver's insurance company that he had chosen his repair shop. He expected them to work directly with that facility. By understanding the modern workflow, he navigated the process smoothly. This ensured his car was repaired to his standards at the shop he trusted.
Feeling unsure about your rights after an accident? The team at Blue Rock Insurance is here to be your advocate. We can help you understand your policy and navigate claims with confidence.
Was this case study helpful? Share it with a friend or family member to help them be prepared, just in case.
